Oh god, not this again. The work of the antidiet crowd asks anyone touched by diet culture to entertain the possibility that body weight doesn’t, in itself, cause health issues.
Unfortunately, this is absolutely not supported by science. Quite the opposite. Even being moderately overweight increases your risk for these ailments to various degrees: diabetes; heart disease; cancer; high blood pressure; complications in pregnancy; kidney disease; fatty liver disease; sleep apnea; osteoarthritis.
And if you’ve read the (wrong) study that being moderately overweight has some protective effect, it was incorrect. See here for why and where it went wrong.
Using data from three large cohort studies, comprising over 225,000 individuals, the researchers demonstrated that, no, there was no protective effect of being overweight. In fact, there was a small, but significant, added risk for all-cause mortality.
This is not quite as horrible as intuitive eating but it’s close. The sad thing is that it is glancingly close to wisdom but instead it dives into the abyss of dopey feelgood inane goofy wishful thinking.
People it seems just want an escape from things just being hard. But that’s life. Sometimes it’s difficult. A slog. A sore trial. There’s no deliverance from this, and definitely none if you want to improve yourself. It makes me really glad I became a paratrooper and did the other very difficult things I did in my life. I know just how hard the world can be. After those tribulations, all else came to seem easy. What stresses other people just seems barely a gnat to me. People wonder how I can just walk out of meetings or confront people in public. But I’ll tell you why. Death held my hand more than a few times, pulled me close in the dark, told me its secrets, and after that I became untouchable, the master of myself. No one else had dominion. Borrowed time is the best time because I never plan on paying it back.
There’s nothing wrong with being weak and soft. I truly believe that. I sometimes wish I were both of those things. My life would’ve been easier. But there’s also no reason to lie about it, to deny the truth of how the world works and the danger you expose yourself and others to with those lies, those distortions.
Even if you are weak and soft, you still owe others truth. Or at least you should.