can we talk about actually why the peloton ad is so bad? the answer isn’t sexism, or that it’s hard to convey an inner journey in an ad
the problem is copywriting
THREAD pic.twitter.com/4RvqVsElQf
— Amy Hoy (@amyhoy) December 5, 2019
People made a lot of presumptions about the scenario that were not at all justified, all based on their own manias and misapprehensions. Many people would be overjoyed to receive a gift like that, even as a surprise.
However, the Peloton ad was written as some oddball pastiche of POV porn, first person shooter, and bad horror movie without any actual horror elements — that’s why it’s a failure. That said, it probably did not read that oddly to millennials and particuarly Gen Z, as that sort of self-objectification is normal and even de rigeur for those generations.