However, mobile apps designed for leisurely entertainment translate badly into complex desktop applications built for power user productivity.
All of this is true:
Using software professionally isn’t about having a chic, boutique experience – it’s about getting the job done as quickly and efficiently as possible. Sometimes, that means working with irreducible complexity.
…
I could swiftly accomplish basic tasks in programs on the various platforms, including management of the programs themselves, such as determining which window was focused, what was a button and not, how to find advanced features, how to learn keyboard shortcuts, etc. Fundamental functions had fixed homes (Save and Open under File, for example) and the way to access them was sufficiently similar. This was efficient (learn one concept, apply it everywhere), easy to use (observe one system/program, operate all of them) and thus satisfying: my skills are transferable!
The core problem is that computers used to be aimed at those experienced with them, and those unafraid of having to learn something and capable of doing so — and usually those with quite high IQs.
Now, computers are aimed at mouth-breathers with the IQ of a turnip who cannot find dog food in a Purina plant. Also, computers and applications have been contaminated by mobile conventions and the useless and harmful paradigms that the mobile restrictions promote, leading to the insanity of (for instance) having no focus indications on windows any longer because mobile does not have that. There are no words for how absurdly stupid that is, and how harmful to usability.
Every current UI designer and their associated MBA overlords should be flung into the sun. The mouth-breathers too, but I think they’d make the sun too dumb to shine. Just Toro chipper-shredder for them, I guess.
I want real usable computers and programs back again. I think what I (and the author of the linked post) object to the most is something that many are too reticent or too afraid of consequences to say, but I’m not. And it’s this: I am not a dumbass, and should not be forced to do the things that dumbasses have to do.