People Die

Jesus Fucking Christ, a fucking naval vessel of a country you’re currently at war with is a legitimate target.

These idjits scream about “war crimes” for things that seem to them uncouth. Guess what? War sucks and people die, often in horrid ways.

Ext Plaus

That is extremely plausible. The time to do this would be when the US is distracted by Iran. I’d also expect China to attempt moves on Taiwan around the same time as Russia attempts to take the Baltic states.

Blam

Damn. Really frigged up that frigate.

Looks real, but could be AI? Why would that be released? Not typical as it gives away capabilities and contact procedure.

Des Dis

Whether you think attacking Iran is right or not, Wil is correct. And I’ll never be sad that the evil bastard Khamenei is dead. I can hardly think of a person who was more deserving of disintegration by a 2,000 pound bomb.

War v. Gen

The IDF is pretty competent. As I’ve pointed out before, if Israel really had wanted to commit a genocide every citizen of Gaza would now be dead.

That was just a war. A brutal one, but a war.

Droning Onward

I was talking about this with a friend and my partner recently. A war with the US involved would not look like this. Drones are not omnipotent nor are they immune from physical reality. Extensive use of drone warfare to the level of the Russia-Ukraine conflict is an artifact of limited personnel, poorly-developed anti-drone defenses (including EW) and lack of funding for superior non-drone resources.

That is, drones are in use so heavily there because it is the best of a lot of bad options. Other players like the United States and China have superior options so any war with major well-resourced nations would not at all look like the Russia-Ukraine War. People really do have trouble contextualizing events and the vicissitudes of fate and circumstance and don’t seem to realize that what’s occurring in Ukraine will not be how war would look everywhere for every combatant.

Note that I am not saying that drones would not be used in, for example, a US-China war. They absolutely would, and heavily. They are now an unavoidable feature of modern warfare. However, the US already has better anti-drone defenses than Ukraine is ever to likely lay hands on. Those are also improving all the time.

Another point: Drones are very large targets on radar, very slow1, and not that powerful. In other words, they are quite easy to shoot down with the appropriate technology. A drone is just a cheap, slow missile, and the US is actually quite good at dealing with those.

Drones appear all-powerful because Russia and Ukraine use them by necessity and have poor counter-drone defenses. That will not be true of every conflict and is very specific to the circumstances of a single war.

  1. By military standards.

Hedging

This writer claims “How ‘Hedgehog Tanks’ Are Forcing Russia and Ukraine to Rewrite Drone Warfare.”

First — and most obviously — this writing is terrible. It’s both breathlessly melodramatic and logorrheic. It sounds like something I would’ve written in middle school on a bad day.

Second, hedgehog tanks are mostly irrelevant to the actual war as they are not very mobile and don’t help the fighting all that much. They are nearly pointless and not all that effective. A tank that can’t maneuver, that has low visibility from inside and that can’t bring its main gun in play to affect anything is just a really poor and low-capacity APC.

So…this essay is just to say — inexpertly and awkwardly — that people try to survive however they can in a war? Bold thesis. Wish I could’ve thought of something like that.

As to the headline, no, hedgehog tanks are not forcing Russia and Ukraine to rewrite drone warfare. Hyperbolic much? Hedgehog tanks aren’t a significant threat so no rewriting is needed. You just send two drones instead of one, or something with an EFP, or one of those top-secret (really) Anduril Altius munitions the Ukrainians have now, or just hit it with a frickin’ Javelin. Javelins don’t care about cope cages, quills, spines, or any such feature.

When people who don’t know anything about modern warfare write about it, you end up with spacey garble like this.

I regret reading this but it’s too late now.