I couldnโt have said it better myself.
Letโs say that we could stop all cultural appropriation tomorrow. No feathered headdress would ever again mar a fashion runway. Blackface would remain a thing of the past. Only those signalling their identification with the Palestinian struggle would wear the keffiyeh. Yet hereโs a sticking point โ since the scarf was once just a symbol of Arab masculinity, should we revert to that? Given that almost every cultural form has been purloined from somewhere else, it proves tricky to tell what belongs to whom, and to separate the offensive jerks from those pursuing respectful cultural innovation. The line between insider and outsider can be surprisingly indistinct.
Obsessing so much over cultural appropriation is to me extremely silly because 99% of everything in every culture everywhere ever has been โappropriatedโ from some other culture.
That is just how humans work.