Only an Econner

Only an economist could believe something so stupid (proven by โ€œevidenceโ€) that H-1B visas are good for American workers. First, over what time scale, and second, in what circumstances?

Oh, companies bring in more H-1Bs and hire more American workers at the same time? And pray tell, when does this happen? When the economy is expanding. Some insight, there. I am getting accustomed to seeing through the typical economist tricks and salary-motivated mistakes so it just doesnโ€™t take me as long as it used to.

This is also common methodological error in economics papers: presume the existence of the item you are claiming benefits the economy and/or workers, and then fail to examine worlds without the existence of said โ€œbeneficialโ€ program as they cannot be tested. Fail to mention this or to account for it in any way. Thus, your paperโ€™s postulation is merely a tautology, though gussied up in a lot of impenetrable mathematical formalism. As Taleb has pointed out, most economics papers have this problem.