T Crap

This paper is absolute horseshit.

I donโ€™t have time to write about all its flaws, but it is complete garbage.

Itโ€™s all a cheap mathematically-engineered analogy, and certainly is not any kind of evidence that the vacuum is an acoustic-like medium or that quantum theory has been derived from classical dispersion. The damn thing starts from Schrรถdinger (Madelung), chooses constitutive laws that force a Coulomb operator, then calibrates with non-derived parameters to hydrogen. That is not in any way a meaningful physical derivation of quantization. Itโ€™s just like if I traced a photo of someone with a pencil and declared I had discovered what they look like from that. No I did not.

This is total crapola and never shouldโ€™ve been published.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *